
Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue
Best for practical downtown stays, extended-stay suites, and easy access to Naples shopping, restaurants and marina activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue is a marina-front, suite-focused extended-stay hotel in downtown Naples for travelers who want easy access to 5th Avenue South and Naples Bay. Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers is a branded beachfront resort on Fort Myers Beach for travelers seeking beachside dining, bars, a spa and resort-style amenities.
Updated

Best for practical downtown stays, extended-stay suites, and easy access to Naples shopping, restaurants and marina activities.

Best for classic branded beach-resort experiences with multiple on-site restaurants, bars, a spa and direct access to Crescent Beach.
When Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue wins: Choose Hyatt House if you want suite-style rooms, a free hot breakfast, a marina-front location steps from 5th Avenue South and easy access to Naples Bay activities (kayaking, fishing, boat tours). It’s a practical pick for families and longer stays who plan to explore Old Naples on foot.
When Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers wins: Pick Margaritaville when your priority is beach access, a full-service spa, multiple dining and bar outlets, resort-feel programming and daytime beachfront leisure on Fort Myers Beach. The Margaritaville name signals a resort experience with lots of on-site amenities and food/drink options.
Bottom line: Both hotels suit relaxed coastal trips, but they serve different needs: Hyatt House Naples is a practical downtown, marina-side extended-stay with family-friendly suites and a strong location for dining and local excursions; Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers is a beachfront, branded resort focused on beachtime, multiple restaurants/bars and spa services.
| Category | Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue | Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-front extended-stay hotel focused on suites and practical amenities | Branded beachfront resort with multiple dining bars, spa and beach programming |
| Location | Downtown Naples at the marina on the Gordon River, steps from 5th Avenue South | On Fort Myers Beach with direct beach access (Crescent Beach) |
| Size (rooms) | 183 suites across 3 floors | 254 air-conditioned rooms |
| Target ages / audience | All ages; family-friendly with family-size suites and kid-friendly breakfast | All ages; not adults-only, family-friendly beach resort |
| Pools & water | One lagoon-style outdoor pool (85,000 gallons) with infinity edge, hot tub and poolside bar/cabanas | Outdoor pool(s) and direct beach access; pool cabanas available (surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | Latitude 26 (American), Morning Spread breakfast, H Bar and 24-hour H Market | Multiple on-site restaurants and 4 bars/lounges plus a beach bar and a coffee shop/cafe |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center; no standalone treatment spa published | Full-service spa with massage treatments published on supplier listing |
| Known for | Marina location, extended-stay suites, free hot breakfast and easy walking access to 5th Avenue South | Branded beach-resort experience, many dining/drinking outlets, beachfront location |
| Fees & extras | Complimentary hot breakfast included; secured covered parking for a fee; complimentary local downtown shuttle | Resort fee and deposit published (resort fee about USD 50.18/night and deposit USD 100/day); valet parking and resort amenities included in resort fee |
| Accessibility & policies | Accessible routes to guest rooms and public areas; minimum check-in age 21; pet policy inconsistent—confirm with hotel | Wheelchair accessible (may have limitations); minimum check-in age 21; pet fee and resort policies published |
| Signature feature | Dockside Boardwalk event space and marina access for kayaking/fishing/boat tours | Branded Margaritaville atmosphere with beach bars, multiple restaurants and a full-service spa |
Hyatt House sits on the Gordon River in Old Naples, directly adjacent to the marina and a short walk to 5th Avenue South.
Best if you want downtown walking access to shops/restaurants and easy marina access.
Margaritaville is a branded resort located on Fort Myers Beach with direct access to Crescent Beach.
Best if your priority is being on the sand with dining and resort amenities steps away.
Hyatt House focuses on suite-style units designed for extended stays and families.
Choose Hyatt House for larger, suite-style rooms and practical conveniences for longer visits.
Margaritaville offers a range of standard and deluxe rooms, including accessible options and gulf-view premium rooms.
Choose Margaritaville when you want typical resort-style rooms with some gulf-view upgrades.
Hyatt House’s dining centers on Latitude 26 plus casual poolside and market options.
Good pick if you want reliable, casual American dining with a waterfront setting and included breakfast.
Margaritaville offers several restaurants, bars and a beachfront bar for varied choices on-site.
Best for variety of on-site dining and beachside bar options so you can stay on-property for most meals.
Hyatt House has a single large lagoon-style pool with marina views and a hot tub.
Better if you want a waterfront pool experience that connects to the marina and downtown Naples.
Margaritaville centers the resort experience on beach access plus resort pools and cabanas.
Better if your main plan is beach time with easy access to pool and cabana services.
Hyatt House emphasizes fitness and on-water activities from the marina.
A practical choice if you want to stay active and book bay excursions from your hotel doorstep.
Margaritaville puts more emphasis on spa services and multiple bars/lounges for daytime and evening activity.
Pick Margaritaville when a spa treatment and lots of on-site bars/food options are priorities.

Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue — suite options, free hot breakfast and family-friendly amenities.

Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers — direct beach access, beach bar and multiple on-site restaurants.

Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue — marina location with easy walking access to 5th Avenue South.

Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers — published full-service spa and many bars/lounges.
Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue — it’s on 5th Avenue South and within easy walking distance of many restaurants, boutiques and galleries.
Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers — it is on Fort Myers Beach with direct access to Crescent Beach and beachside bars and loungers.
Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue includes a complimentary hot breakfast for registered guests. Margaritaville offers breakfast but the supplier listing shows it as available for a surcharge.
Margaritaville Beach Resort Fort Myers publishes a full-service spa with massage treatments; Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue does not list a standalone spa on its official property page (hot tub/spa tub noted).
Explore how Hyatt House Naples/5th Avenue stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·